We are grateful to serve you!

We are honored to receive this award from Restarant Guru! Thank you for recommending The Cheesecake Lady Indy and allowing us to cater to you and your families!

Indy's favorite place for desserts and cheesecake! You now have the luxury of ordering your favorite desserts and cheesecake at your fingertips!

Meet the Owner

Founded in 2020, Cassie Smith-Johnson a.k.a The Cheesecake Lady took a leap of faith and pursued her dream of becoming an entrepreneur. She always had a love and passion for cheesecake. (after all it is her favorite dessert)

She took the time to learn how to incorporate various flavors into the simple dessert she loves so much. She is now serving her homemade recipe to customers throughout Indianapolis, IN and the surrounding areas.

Specialty Cakes

Our specialty cakes are pre-order only. Pictured here is our Strawberry Crunch Banana Pudding Combo Cake. Yellow cake with a heavy layer of cheesecake topped with vanilla wafers and our strawberry crunch blend!

Call us to pre-order your customized specialty cake at 317-608-7411, or select any avaible flavor combinations listed on our website.

Catering available!

Wedding, bridal shower, baby shower, open house or whatever the special occasion, we can cater your event!

Shown here is our dessert shooters and 8oz cheesecake cups. Our full menu is available for catering. Call or Email us to discuss your catering needs.

FAQ's & Policies


Turn Around Time For Orders:

Online orders are allotted a minimum of 48 hours to be fulfilled. Exceptions may be made by processing your order by phone at 317-608-7411.

** For all pick up orders ID is required, name on id must match name on order**

We will notify you via email or text informing you your order has been prepared and is ready for pick up.

Delivery will only be avaible for catering orders.

For all catering inquiries please send an email to thecheesecakeladyindy@gmail.com or call 317-608-7411

**Special hours and holiday closures will be posted**