Indy's favorite place for desserts and cheesecake! You now have the luxury of ordering your favorite desserts and cheesecake at your fingertips!

Meet the Owner

Founded in 2020, Cassie Smith-Johnson a.k.a The Cheesecake Lady took a leap of faith and pursue her dream of becoming an entrepreneur. She always had a love and passion for cheesecake. (after all it is her favorite dessert)

She took the time to learn how to incorporate various flavors into the simple dessert she loves so much. She is now serving her homemade recipe to customers throughout Indianapolis, IN and the surrounding areas.

Specialty Cakes

Our specialty cakes are pre-order. Pictured here is our Strawberry Crunch Banana Pudding Combo. Yellow cake with a heavy layer of cheesecake! Email us to pre-order this specialty cake! Choose from any of our specialty and deluxe flavors for your custom specialty cake!

Catering available!

Wedding, bridal shower, open house or whatever the occasion is, we can cater for your event! Shown here is our desert shooters and cheesecake bowls. Our full menu is available. Email us to place your catering requests.

FAQ's & Policies

FAQ's

Turn Around Time For Orders:

Cake/Pie Orders require 48 hours all other orders take 24 hours

** For all pick up orders ID is required, name on id must match name on order**

Free Delivery on orders of $50 or more. $7 delivery fee order minimum $20

Delivery Hours are 4pm-8pm

For all catering inquiries please send an email to thecheesecakeladyindy@gmail.com or call 317-608-7411

**Special hours and holiday closures will be posted**

Refund Policy & Order Modifications

All orders cancelled within 1 hour of being placed will receive a full refund.
Thereafter, only partial refunds will be given as orders may have already been prepared.


Order modifications must be made within an hour of the original submission